Currently a Pex generated lockfile can contain sdists from various sources. When building a PEX from such a lockfile and one of the sdist artifacts is selected, it must be built into a wheel. If the sdist utilizes PEP-518 build-system requires, that resolve is not locked. As a result building the same PEX on two different dates can pick up changes in the build system resolve and lead to a wheel with different content.
On the harmless side, we've seen this build-system requires:
[build-system]
requires = ["pdm-pep517>=1.0.0"]
Lead to built wheels with differing contents due to:
$ unzip -qc emote_rl-23.0.0-py3-none-any.whl emote_rl-23.0.0.dist-info/WHEEL
Wheel-Version: 1.0
Generator: pdm-pep517 1.1.3
Root-Is-Purelib: True
Tag: py3-none-any
In other words, even if the rest of the generated wheel has the same content, the Generator: pdm-pep517 1.1.3 line in the WHEEL metadata will be different when the build system releases an update.
Ideally, Pex could guaranty reproducibility here by including an extra lock per sdist that locks in its build-system requires and then Pex could use these extra locks when building wheels from the sdists later to form a reproducible PEX from the lock.
Currently a Pex generated lockfile can contain sdists from various sources. When building a PEX from such a lockfile and one of the sdist artifacts is selected, it must be built into a wheel. If the sdist utilizes PEP-518 build-system requires, that resolve is not locked. As a result building the same PEX on two different dates can pick up changes in the build system resolve and lead to a wheel with different content.
On the harmless side, we've seen this build-system requires:
Lead to built wheels with differing contents due to:
In other words, even if the rest of the generated wheel has the same content, the
Generator: pdm-pep517 1.1.3line in the WHEEL metadata will be different when the build system releases an update.Ideally, Pex could guaranty reproducibility here by including an extra lock per sdist that locks in its build-system requires and then Pex could use these extra locks when building wheels from the sdists later to form a reproducible PEX from the lock.